Thursday, May 5, 2011
New Mother EMS
Colossus EMS
An interesting thing i found from the poem was the flower references. You have "the weedy acres of your brow", "a hill of black cypress", "acanthine hair", and "scrape of a keel" (which can mean a pair of united petals in a flower). These aren't the happy 'roses are red, violets are blue' flower references. It seems that Plath is trying to imply organic growth rather than pretty flowers. This organic life is also shown in the first stanza from the lines "Mule-bray, pig-grunt and bawdy cackles / Proceed from your great lips. / It's worse than a barnyard." Again, these aren't pleasant noises, and this time she seems to be making a direct attack at her father.
Tuesday, May 3, 2011
Lady Lazarus EMS
It seems obvious that these suicide attempts are referring to Plath's actual suicide attempts. She tried to kill herself at 20, and killed herself at 30. The accidental death referred to in the poem could be a near-death experience for her when she was younger, or possibly a reference to her father's death at 8.
While the poem centers on the return from death, it also includes a few references to her being the center of attention to her critics. These critics, "The peanut-crunching crowd / Shove in to see / Them unwrap me hand and foot--- / The big strip tease." This seems to be a reference to how Plath puts so much of her personal pain into her work, and can be see in the words "Dying / Is an art". She seems to resent her apparent selling-out of her pain, throuigh the lines "There is a charge / For the eyeing of my scars" and "And there is a charge, a very large charge / For a word or a touch / Or a bit of blood". She seems to be selling her pain, something that she really seems to detest.
Like some of Plath's other poetry, she seems to villify her father as a nazi. She says "So, so, Herr Doktor. So, Herr Enemy." She describes the way the nazis sifted through the ashes of their victims to find gold, and makes the imagery of a phoenix with "Out of the ash / I rise with my red hair / And i eat men like air." This imagery seems to suggest Plath believes that through her misery brought on by her father
The Japanese Wife EMS
First Kiss EMS
There seems to be something tragic about the woman in this poem. She seems to be reminiscing about her daughter's infancy, making it sound like she was a while away from that point. It then seems from when the man "leaned back against a chain-link fence, / in front of a burned-out church" Those lines make it seem as though the woman is the burned-out church. She seems to also be at a loss of power, first being helpless to her daughter, and then to this man, and in both scenario's it is because she is stronger than the other and has something they want.
river merchant's wife EMS
The second stanza begins with the narrator being 14, and marrying the river-merchant. At this point, the wife "never laughed, being bashful." We still see the youth in her, still making the transition to being a wife. The next stanza, when she turns 15, she starts to mature, when she "stopped scowling". She starts at this point to love her husband, saying she "desired my dust to be mingled with yours / Forever and forever and forever." This is certainly a shift from before.
During the fourth stanza, the wife turns 16, and the river-merchant leaves. The line "The monkeys make sorrowful noise overhead" shows the manifestation of the wife's sorrow. The last stanza shows even more of this manifestation, with a different moss growing where the old moss was that the river-merchant walked. The wife is getting older, and yearns for her husband. She asks that if he is "coming down through the narrows of the river Kiang", if he would let her know, so she can come to meet him.
The most significant part of this poem for me is the transition of the romance. The relationship goes from indifference, to just a marriage without significant love, to love, then despair and longing. Something beautiful to it.
The Flea EMS
The original question I had after reading this poem was whether the husband and wife had sex already. It seems from looking at the poem, though, that they had already. The line "nor loss of maidenhead" seems to suggest the wife is not a virgin already. When you add that with the line "Though parents grudge, and you, we're met", it suggests through "we're met" that they have had sex, and it can possibly be read that it was a forced marriage due to premarital sex. And could this premarital sex have led to a baby? There is certainly baby imagery through the flea, a third party, containing the mixed blood of the two parents. I don't feel like this is the case, although an argument could certainly be said that abortion is included in the poem, as the wife seems to have killed the flea, potentially meaning that she killed the child.
Sunday, May 1, 2011
Mock orange VH
In Mock Orange there are five stanzas. She talks about how she hates flowers and compare them to sex. She then talks about the acts that are done during sex and how it is humiliating and says she doesn’t like it. She also compares the scent of the flowers to the scent of sex in lines 21 to 26. Throughout these poems she detests sex with a comparison to mock orange.
For my daughter VH
This poem is 12 lines long with a rhyming scheme of ababccdedeffgg. The poem is speaking of the death of his daughter. She has died and he is mourning for her throughout the poem. It seems as if he is bitter that his daughter has not made it. The whole poem is description of how he feels about losing the daughter. In the end he says “I desire none” but that is false obviously because he is bitter that he lost his daughter.
Colossus VH
The poem has six stanzas and doesn’t have a rhyming scheme. It is clear that the poem is speaking about her father but only so if you have a little bit of outside knowledge of her life. If you know about her past you would be able to connect the dots quickly. She is very angry at her father because he passed away and wasn’t there for her. She holds it against him and has not forgiven him for not being there.
The title is very important because throughout the poem she discusses how significant an impact on her life her father’s death has had. She also compares herself to small things when she is speaking of herself and him. She makes him seem so much larger and more important than herself hence Colossus is an appropriate title.
In the first stanza she states that she doesn’t understand “him” also saying that the sound off his lips are those of farm animals. “Mule-Bray, pig grunted and bawdy cackles” She then proceeds to say that he is worse than those animals.
The next thing that jumps out is in the third stanza. She compares herself to an ant in mourning. That image makes you think of all kinds of thing. I imagine an ant in mourning means that because she is even lower and smaller than an ant and very insignificant. She says that’s how she feels in his presence.
“I open my lunch on a hill of black cypress” has a connection to death because it is commonly known as a tree used to decorate cemeteries. So that is another hint that she is talking about her father who died. In the following stanza she begins to speak on the impact of her father’s death saying that when he left is more ruining then a lightning stroke. This is a comparison that is describing the impact her father not being there had on her life.
Tuesday, April 26, 2011
Shakespeare sonnet 18 MP
Tuesday, April 19, 2011
Anne Sexton Article
1. The mad writer approach such as Edgar Allen Poe and Sylvia Plath that battle with "inner demons" in their poetry, and
2. therapeutic creative writing, where individuals use writing to cope with a difficult situation in their life and it has helped them overcome that problem.
The article states that although these two concepts are complete polar opposites, there seems to be a relationship-those with emotional or mental trouble leaning towards creative writing as an outlet of emotions.
The author first makes an analysis of mental illnesses but, unlike one of the three articles we read a few weeks ago, it uses the references very well and even states that "making distinctions can be particularly prone to error". Without manipulating the data, the author states how there is a high correlation between suicide rates and artists, such as writers or poets. Furthermore, suicidal poets tend to write for the self "revealing inward focus". It shows that they are socially shy as opposed to their non-suicidal mates. Schizophrenia is also mentioned to be another factor.
This article then starts talking about the Sylvia Plath effect as well. Female poets tend to pay attention to their depression, whereas male poets apparently tend to distract themselves, thus they are less likely to be suicidal.
Dream Songs
His style is usually writing in tercepts, quatrains, or a mixture of the two. His diction and grammar is very odd, although they are purposely written that way. Why they are written this way is a bit unclear but to me, it sounds like the poem is more raw, or, more original-giving it a very freestyle writing image, as if it were fresh from his thoughts without careful revision or any revision at all.
3 Articles on Sylvia Plath (M.A)
The article talks about how female poets are more affected and prone to mental illnesses than male poets or other kind of artists, such as visual artists or prose writers. It has a very generalized analysis of the data, taking different types of experiments and just fitting them in to the topic of the paper. It is also very repetitive in its data and I find it very generalized. The article does not seem to have substantial data to prove its point. The article's beginning is also very negative, as to me, I did not want to read it anymore because of its pessimistic tone. Furthermore, it states that female poets tend to have the "Sylvia Plath" effect because poets start off as mentally unstable and it worsens when the poetry does not help them resolve their mental or emotional problems. It stated that although writing can be helpful for people to let go of emotions or deal with situations, it is unclear how valuable and helpful poetry is due to the statistics of female poets developing mental issues and their suicide rate.
Sylvia Plath and the Failure of Emotional Self-Repair
In this article, three dualities were listed by the author:
1. balance between creative individual's use of the audience to serve her own narcissistic interests
2. balance between destructive and constructive activity
3. interplay between pretense and fantasy.
The article talks about how Plath realized that poetry was self-destructing for her, yet she still kept writing poems. Some themes that were major themes of Plath's poems were her father's sudden death, and about suicide and pain as well.
Sylvia Plath: Fusion of the victim and suicide
According to the author, Sylvia Plath was able to use poetry to resolve some of her emotional and mental issues but it states that the poems would backfire and haunt her again, which it did. It also stated that if the poems are read in order (i.e. chronologically), it shows how Plath is forcing against death but towards the end of her life, the poems forces against death and suicide weaken, which shows her weakened stability of mind and her attraction towards suicide.
Sexton - BK
Anne Sexton - Poetry/Articles - Jeet
The essence of the first article lies in two theories - 1) The Writing Cure 2) The Sylvia Plath Effect.
According the "writing cure", expressive and narrative writing about personal and emotional experiences ought to have therapeutic benefits for the mentally ill/depressed. According to the Sylvia Plath effect, women tend to ruminate more than men and are more affected by external constraints. These and other factors, combined with a non-narrative style of composing poetry may prove to be deleterious to the mental health of female poets. Anne Sexton was recommended to write for therapeutic reasons. Unlike Sylvia Plath however, her work is decidedly non-narrative in nature. Sexton carefully crafts her poems to elicit certain emotions and sympathies without explicitly narrating the underlying story.
"Even then I have nothing against life.
I know well the grass blades you mention,
the furniture you have placed under the sun.
But suicides have a special language.
Like carpenters they want to know which tools.
They never ask why build."
In these lines, Sexton uses grass blades and furniture to signify the emotions she identifies
with feeling positively about life. Yet, it is unclear exactly what she is talking about. Perhaps, grass blades signify fertility and furniture hints at domesticity. Going back to her justification for suicides, she employs the somewhat distant analogy of carpenters. A clear storyline rarely emerges in Sexton's work. According to the writing cure, it is the narrative aspect that is most beneficial since it allows the writer to make meaning out of events and move on. In Anne Sexton's case, perhaps the lack of narrative meant she was constantly drudging up the traumatic experiences in her life and dwelling on their detrimental emotional effects through her poetry.
The second article looks at contemporary views on suicide and offers brief explications of Sexton’s poems – “Wanting to Die” and “Suicide Note”. A major distinction is made between euthanasia and other suicides. In our society, some sympathy is conferred upon the former; the latter always invites some repugnance and fear. In “Wanting to Die”, Sexton tries to persuade the reader of a rationality that might underlie a suicide that arises simply out of mental agony. She tries to establish suicide as natural and innocent when she speaks of children pondering upon the “sweet drug”. She hints that people might be born with a detached mental state that they cannot continue living with. Since they weren’t still born, it is rational that they wish to return to their state in the womb, where the first boundary between life and death exists.
The third article goes in depth into some linguistic research that was also cited in the first article. Suicidal poets tend to be more inward focused and a linguistic analysis of their writing confirms this. For instance, they use the first person singular noticeably more than the non-suicidal poets.
Anne Sexton Poems and Article- VB
Anne Sexton's poetry did have many hintings towards suicide but I feel she used her writing as a coping mechanism just like her close friend Sylvia Plath. However, just like Plath eventually neither of them were able to handle living in this world and took their own lives. Poetry was a release for them because they clearly had something unstable or wrong either in their minds or in their lives and poetry allowed them to express themselves in ways they could not in person. I believe that poetry also contributed to their suicides because it allowed them to get through situations without getting real help. They could only express their anger they could never confront the problems head on in their lives and caused the eventual breakdown of their mental health to the point where they took their own lives.
I feel that when reading poems written by Anne Sexton it is easy to make the connection that she is suicidal. However, I am not sure that I could have concluded that she committed suicide just by reading her poetry. She is very talented but it seems that her mental instability which was apparent in her poetry eventually wore her down. It would be interesting to see how different her life would have been without poetry.
Thursday, April 14, 2011
Anne Sexton Articles/Poetry - R. Abbott
Tuesday, April 5, 2011
Dream Song - AS
Mr. Bones and Me, EMS
Dream Songs - BK
Dream Songs - Jeet
The poems had a very personal feel and the writing style complemented that very well. After reading up on the poet's background, it is apparent why that personal feel is so obvious. The dream songs are a collection of largely confessional poetry with the gentleman Henry serving as an alter ego. The descriptions of Henry are very much a parallel to Berryman's own life.
"In a modesty of death I join my father/ who dared so long agone leave me." This line from dream song 76 is a clear allusion to his father's suicide and perhaps even foreshadows his own life. Dream song 77 narrates Henry's exasperation with life and foreshadows his tragic suicide.
"These fierce and airy occupations, and love, / raved away so many of Henry's years/...his head full/ & his heart full, he's making ready to move on."
In dream song 74, Berryman writes about the lack of love by describing how the holiest and prettiest cities in the world cannot make up for the "unlove" in Henry's life. Some of Berryman's distaste for the world and perhaps his emotional/societal instability is apparent in the following lines - "Henry hates the world. What the world to Henry/ did will not bear thought"
Dream song 5 also captures the confessional nature of Berryman's poetry.
"Henry sat in the bar and was odd,/off in the glass from the glass,/ at odds wif de world and its god,/ his wife is a complete nothing,/ St Stephen getting even."
This single stanza touches upon Berryman's alcohol abuse, his anti-social streak and his struggle with a failed marriage.
Having said all that, I was very confused about large parts of the poems.
Dream Songs MQ
Dream Songs MP
Dream Songs-WR-
In his poems, Berryman uses name “Henry”. Henry can be Berryman himself, or his ideal friend, but it seems obvious that Henry and Berryman shares memories and feelings. Also most of his poem has three stanzas and each stanza has six lines. Also Berryman never uses word “and” in his poem. But he uses character “&” to replace the word.
Monday, April 4, 2011
Dream Songs-FK
Sunday, April 3, 2011
Dream Songs - R. Abbott
Thursday, March 31, 2011
3 Articles-FK
Bask in the Dreams of Suicide VH
I Bask in the Dreams of Suicide:
This article discussed the research that highlights the relationship between mental illness and poets. It was pointed out that scientific research has been done and that research has discovered that many poets suffer from mental illnesses. They also discovered that poetry attracts those with a mental illness and although poetry may help those with a mental illness it may also cause one to obtain a mental illness. Also the research pointed out that woman are caused a great amount of physiological stress from poetry. Overall the idea was that Tendencies of mental illness are greater in artistic fields of work.
3 article -WR-
“I Bask In Dreams of Suicide: Mental Illness, Poetry, and Women” . The purpose of the article is to explore possible reasons for the high rate of mental illness among female poets. The authors also give some examples of the linkage between creativity and mental illness, especially in the domain of poetry and among female poets. In the article Sylvia Plath is introduced as an example of a female eminent poet who committed suicide.
“Sylvia Plath And The Failure Of Emotional Self-repair Through Poetry” This article is about Sylvia Plath’s life. The author tries to find the reason why Sylvia Plath committed suicide and what effect her decision. In the article introduce two important events that effect Sylvia’s decision. The first event was Sylvia’s mother’s visiting to England possibly stirring up her old fears of her father. And the second event was Sylvia’s husband’s affair with another woman.
Articles - Jeet
- Empirical studies have established a link between mental illness and creative writers/artists; female poets in particular
- Poetry attracts more expressive, emotional, "narrative", "legislative" thinkers who are more prone to instability. Depressed women tend to ruminate more than men and writing may have a deleterious effect. The personal nature of poetry attracts emotionally disturbed women looking for an outlet.
- Poetry may not have the same benefits as other creative writing and might adversely impact the artist's internal locus of control, and therefore his or her self esteem. Female poets in particular tend to attribute their accomplishments to an external agent such as a muse.
- The "gatekeepers" of poetry may have ingrained expectations about the personal nature of a female poet's work and therefore may view the works of emotionally unstable female poets in a more favorable light.
- Mental illness is more prevalent in the young population and compared to artists and professionals in other fields, poets tend to peak earlier in their lives.
- Female poets in western society might struggle more than men to deal with the higher expectations that accompany creative success.
- The dualities - a)Writing for an audience and writing for personal reasons. b) Destructive and constructive activity within writing. c) Fantasy and pretense as opposed to reality. d) Interplay and harmony between content and form
- In Plath's later years, the emotionally devastating experiences of her life, coupled with her unstable mental state and her narcissistic withdrawal from the world led to her abandoning her controlled traditional style of composing poetry. She adopted a more a much more personal style that let her feelings run loose, only heightening her inner turmoil.
I'm not sure if i understand the article. The implication seems to be that Plath's poetry gave her a venue to vent her rage and control her swirling mass of ambivalent emotions. However, in her later years, the creative force weakened and the absence of this coping mechanism led her to kill herself. (?)
Wednesday, March 30, 2011
3 articles - BK
Tuesday, March 29, 2011
3 Articles - R. Abbott
The Colossus (M.A)
In the second stanza, she describes how her father considers what he says to be important and maybe is therefore trying to say something. But she states that even after thirty years, she still does not know what the sounds mean that he made.
In the third stanza, she describes how she is trying to clean his face with disinfectant.. slowly "like an ant in mourning" over his bushy eyebrows and cleaning his eyes. This creates a segway into the fourth stanza of his expressive looks that are "pithy and historical". This metaphor is compared to the Roman history.
In the fifth stanza she describes how her father's physical and mental ability have been ruined and that it takes "more than a lightning-stroke to create such a ruin". She realizes that it isn't a normal illness that can be cured and a lot of damage has been done.
In the sixth stanza, her message is a bit confusing but it seems like she is just trying to say that she doesn't have to hear those harsh noises anymore.
The Colossus MQ
The Colossus - Jeet
She starts off the poem by likening his didactic speech with the senseless sound of beasts. She says that while he himself might have had a high opinion of the wisdom he was imparting, she for one never could make sense of it.
She speaks of herself as an ant in mourning, a small creature in his overbearing presence. In alluding to the skies of the Greek tragedies and the Roman Forum, she is indicating that while he didn't offer her anything of value, he still is a very significant part of her life, which at times was rather depressing for her.
The reference to cypress and the symbolism that associates that tree to death and funerals indicates the father's continued significance even after death; and that death had such a profound impact on her that it must have been caused by something much more powerful than even lightening.
"My hours are married to shadow" - in thinking of her dead father all the time, her life is somehow linked inextricably to death. She has given up on being conscious about the more easily perceptible things (emotions) in life.
The actual description of the father is also linked to the stone colossus (statue) and lends itself to comparison with a stony, unmoving figure that is a big part of her life. In this, the poem may be thought of as an extended simile/ deceit.
The Colossus MP
The Colossus-VB
The Colossus-WR-
Monday, March 28, 2011
The Colossus-FK
The Colossus - BK
Thursday, March 24, 2011
'The Colossus' - R. Abbott
LAdy Lazarus-WR-
The poem really made me sad because I felt her weakness throughout the poem. In the seven stanza and third line she wrote, “And like the cat I have nine times to die”. She may believe she could live until ninety years old because she said she “done it again one year in every ten…”(1). When she wrote the poem, she was still young. She did not live enough to say the world is terrible. The overall image is of the poem is very dark and painful. However, after reading this poem, I only had one thought in my mind. I really wanted to help her.
Lady Lazarus (M.A)
The poem seems to be about dying three times out of nine. She refers to herself as a cat, because it is a myth that cat have nine lives. She starts talking about her injuries, of how her right foot was "like paperweight", which means she couldn't feel it and it was broken.
She then mentions how she has gone through this three times, although the first one was an accident, and the other two were purposely done. That means that the first time she had an accidental near death experience and the other two were suicide attempts.